Religious Holidays at Work: Your Scheduling Rights in Indiana

Religious Holidays at Work: Your Scheduling Rights in Indiana

Reviewed by Amber Boyd Moorman

Christmas Eve, Yom Kippur, Eid, Diwali, Good Friday: holiday seasons and religious calendars do not always match the work schedule. If your faith requires you to be off, federal law may require your employer to work with you, even if the schedule is tight. This guide explains what an employer has to do, when it can say no, and what to do if your request is denied.

For the broader rules, see our guide to religious discrimination at work in Indiana.

Can I get time off work for a religious holiday in Indiana?

Often, yes. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act requires employers with 15 or more employees to reasonably accommodate an employee’s sincerely held religious beliefs and practices, unless doing so would cause undue hardship (42 U.S.C. § 2000e(j)).

That can include:

  • time off for a holy day, paid or unpaid
  • a shift swap with a willing coworker
  • a flexible start or end time
  • using PTO or a floating holiday
  • changing your schedule for a recurring observance

The law does not require paid time off for religious holidays. Often the accommodation is simply unpaid time or a schedule change. Indiana also has no law requiring private employers to close or give paid time off for any holiday.

What counts as a religious belief?

Title VII protects more than major or well-known faiths. It covers all aspects of religious observance and practice, including beliefs that are new, uncommon, or not shared by others in your faith. The EEOC explains this in its guidance on religious discrimination.

Purely personal or cultural preferences are different. Wanting Christmas week off for family time is not, on its own, a religious need. If your request has both religious and personal reasons, explain the religious part clearly.

When can an employer say no?

Only if the accommodation would cause undue hardship, and that is harder to show than it used to be. In Groff v. DeJoy, 600 U.S. 447 (2023), the U.S. Supreme Court rejected the old rule that an employer only had to show more than a trivial cost. Now the employer must show that the burden is substantial in the overall context of its business, meaning substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business.

Under Groff:

  • Coworker complaints are not enough alone. Effects on coworkers count only to the extent they affect the conduct of the business.
  • Dislike of your religion never counts. Animosity toward religion, or toward the idea of accommodating it, is off the table.
  • Your employer must look at other options. It cannot stop at “the schedule won’t work.” It should consider options such as voluntary swaps.
  • Business size and type matter. What is a heavy burden for a five-person shift may not be for a large hospital system.

An Indiana case shows how fact-specific this is. In Kluge v. Brownsburg Community School Corp., No. 24-1942 (7th Cir. Aug. 5, 2025), the Seventh Circuit held that a jury had to decide whether an accommodation caused undue hardship under Groff. That case was not about holidays, but it shows courts will not simply take an employer’s word for it.

Popular days off and first-come rules

Many workplaces use seniority or a first-come system for holidays. Those rules are not illegal, but they do not automatically end the discussion. Your employer may still need to consider whether a swap or other change would work without substantial burden. A policy of “no time off in December” is not by itself an undue hardship.

Employers also cannot favor one faith. If it gives Christmas off, it cannot refuse to consider a similar request for another tradition just because the holiday is less familiar.

How to ask for religious time off

  1. Ask early and in writing. Give the date, and say the request is for a religious observance.
  2. Be clear, not exhaustive. You generally do not have to give a long explanation of your beliefs, though your employer may ask a few questions if it has a good reason to doubt the request.
  3. Offer solutions. Suggest a swap, working another holiday, or making up the time.
  4. Keep copies of the request and every response.

Your employer does not have to give you the exact accommodation you prefer, as long as what it offers is reasonable.

What if my request is denied?

Ask for the reason in writing, and ask what other options were considered. If you are refused, disciplined, or fired, you may have a claim. An employer cannot make your need for an accommodation a motivating factor in a decision, even if it never received a formal request (EEOC v. Abercrombie & Fitch, 575 U.S. 768 (2015)).

A schedule change can also matter. The Supreme Court held in Muldrow v. City of St. Louis, 601 U.S. 346 (2024) that an employee challenging a job change under Title VII need only show some harm, not significant harm.

Retaliating against you for asking is also illegal. Read more about workplace retaliation.

Deadlines and where to file

You generally have 300 days to file a religious discrimination charge with the EEOC in Indiana, and 180 days with the Indiana Civil Rights Commission. See how to file an EEOC complaint in Indiana.

Two Indiana points are worth knowing. Indiana’s civil rights law covers religion and generally reaches employers with six or more employees, though it excludes religious employers. And Indiana’s Religious Freedom Restoration Act does not help here, because it does not allow claims against private employers (Ind. Code § 34-13-9-11).

Frequently asked questions

Does my employer have to pay me for a religious holiday?

Generally no. The duty is to accommodate, which often means unpaid time, PTO, or a schedule change.

Can my employer ask for proof of my religion?

Usually employers should accept a sincere request. If it has an objective reason to question it, it may ask for limited information.

Can I be told to find my own replacement?

An employer may let you arrange voluntary swaps, but it should not simply put the whole job on you and call that an accommodation.

What if I am new or still in my probation period?

Title VII protections apply from the start, including to job applicants.

Does this apply to a small business?

Title VII applies at 15 or more employees. Smaller employers may be covered by Indiana law. Talk to a lawyer about your workplace.

Does a coworker complaining make it an undue hardship?

Not on its own. The question is whether the effect on coworkers actually harms the conduct of the business.

Talk to an Indiana employment lawyer

If your employer refused a religious request or punished you for making one, contact Amber Boyd Law for a free case evaluation. You can also learn about our workplace discrimination work.

This article provides general information about Indiana and federal employment law. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

author avatar
admin
Workplace rights blog covering Indiana employment law: ADA accommodations, retaliation, sexual harassment, non-compete. Expert articles & resources.