Year-End Bonuses and Commissions in Indiana: What You Can Actually Collect

Year-End Bonuses and Commissions in Indiana: What You Can Actually Collect

Reviewed by Amber Boyd Moorman

A year-end bonus can be a big part of what you earn, so it hurts when it disappears. Indiana does not require employers to pay bonuses. But once one has been promised, you may be able to enforce it, and the type of claim you have can change what you can recover. This guide explains how Indiana treats bonuses and commissions, what happens if you leave before payout, and what to do if your employer does not pay.

For help with other unpaid pay, see our guide to filing a wage claim in Indiana.

Is a bonus considered wages in Indiana?

Sometimes, but many bonuses are not. The Indiana Supreme Court has said a bonus counts as a wage if it is compensation for time worked and is not linked to a contingency, such as the company’s financial success (Highhouse v. Midwest Orthopedic Institute, 807 N.E.2d 737 (Ind. 2004)).

The label your employer uses does not decide this. Here is how the test tends to work:

  • More likely a wage: a set amount paid regularly, based on the time you worked and not on company results.
  • Less likely a wage: a bonus tied to company profit, team results, or a formula that cannot be calculated until long after the work was done.
  • Usually not a wage: a purely discretionary bonus, such as a surprise holiday gift.

In McCausland v. Walter USA, Inc., 918 N.E.2d 420 (Ind. Ct. App. 2009), commissions and bonuses tied to team or company results were not wages. That surprises a lot of employees. The good news is that this is not the end of the road.

Why it matters whether a bonus is a wage

A bonus that is not a wage can still be owed as a matter of contract. In Highhouse itself, the bonus was not a wage, but the employee could still recover it as a contract matter. The difference is what you can recover and how long you have.

Wage claimContract claim
Applies toPay that meets the wage testA promise your employer made
Extra recoveryAttorney fees, and up to double more in bad-faith casesGenerally the amount owed
Typical deadline2 yearsOften longer if the promise was in writing

Under the Indiana Wage Payment Statute, an employer that fails to pay wages must pay them plus attorney fees. If it did not act in good faith, it can owe two times the wages on top of that (Ind. Code § 22-2-5-2). Older articles describe a different penalty formula, which has been replaced.

What about commissions?

Commissions are listed in Indiana’s wage statutes, but they are not automatically wages. Courts look at how the commission is earned and paid (Bragg v. Kittle’s Furniture, 52 N.E.3d 908 (Ind. Ct. App. 2016)).

Indiana courts have generally said a commission is earned when the order is accepted, unless the agreement or the parties’ conduct clearly shows something else (Vector Engineering & Mfg. Corp. v. Pequet, 431 N.E.2d 503 (Ind. Ct. App. 1982)). But agreements can change that. A clear clause that ends commissions after you leave can be enforced. Read your commission plan closely, especially the sections on when a commission is “earned” and what happens at separation.

Discretionary or not: where that does matter

The word “discretionary” matters most in two places:

  • Contract claims. “You will receive” reads like a promise. “May receive, at the company’s sole discretion” does not.
  • Overtime. Under federal law, nondiscretionary bonuses must be included in your regular rate when overtime is calculated. A bonus is only excluded if the employer kept discretion over both whether and how much to pay until near the end of the period, with no earlier promise (29 C.F.R. § 778.211). If you earn overtime and a promised bonus, your overtime may be short. See Indiana overtime rules.

What if I quit or get fired before the payout date?

It depends on the plan language. Many plans require you to be employed on the payout date, and courts often enforce clear conditions. Look for language like “must be actively employed on the date of payment.”

A few situations deserve a closer look:

  • You were fired shortly before the payout, after meeting the goals.
  • The plan says nothing about leaving before payment.
  • Your employer changed the rules after you had done the work.
  • You were on FMLA or other protected leave and were cut from the bonus for that reason.

Anything that counts as wages is due with your final pay. Indiana has two statutes for this, and the rules differ slightly depending on whether you quit or were let go. Our final paycheck guide explains the timing.

When a missing bonus may be discrimination or retaliation

Even a purely discretionary bonus cannot be denied for an illegal reason. If you were left out because of race, sex, age, disability, or religion, or right after you complained or took protected leave, you may have a separate claim. Being paid less than coworkers doing equal work because of sex may also raise Equal Pay Act issues. Those claims have much shorter deadlines. See Indiana claim deadlines.

Deadlines

  • Wage claims: generally 2 years (Ind. Code § 34-11-2-1).
  • Written contracts for payment of money: generally 6 years (Ind. Code § 34-11-2-9).
  • Oral promises: talk to a lawyer quickly. The deadline may be shorter than you expect.

Who you file with can also depend on how you left. Employees who still work there or who quit generally use the Wage Payment Statute. Those who were fired or laid off generally go through the Indiana Department of Labor first (St. Vincent Hospital v. Steele, 766 N.E.2d 699 (Ind. 2002)).

What to do now

  1. Find the plan, offer letter, handbook, and any emails about the bonus.
  2. Save your numbers: sales reports, quotas, and past bonus statements.
  3. Ask in writing how the bonus was calculated or why it was not paid.
  4. Do not sign a release or severance agreement until you know what you are giving up. A severance agreement can waive a bonus claim.

Frequently asked questions

Does Indiana law require a year-end bonus?

No. A bonus is owed only if it was promised or earned under your agreement or plan.

Are bonuses wages in Indiana?

Some are. A bonus paid for time worked and not tied to a contingency, such as company profit, can be a wage. Many year-end bonuses are not, though they can still be owed under a contract.

Can my employer take back a promised bonus?

It depends on the wording. A truly discretionary bonus can usually be withheld. A clear promise that you met the terms of is harder to take back.

Do I get my commission if I leave before the customer pays?

Check your plan. Indiana courts generally treat a commission as earned when the order is accepted, but your agreement can say otherwise.

My bonus was left out of my overtime. Is that legal?

If the bonus was nondiscretionary, it generally must be included in your regular rate for overtime.

Can I be fired so I lose my bonus?

Indiana is an at-will state, so this may not be illegal on its own. It may support a contract claim, and it is illegal if the real reason is discrimination or retaliation. Talk to a lawyer about the facts.

Get help with an unpaid bonus or commission

If a promised bonus or commission did not show up, contact Amber Boyd Law for a free case evaluation. We help Indiana workers with unpaid wages and pay disputes.

This article provides general information about Indiana and federal employment law. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

author avatar
admin
Workplace rights blog covering Indiana employment law: ADA accommodations, retaliation, sexual harassment, non-compete. Expert articles & resources.