Disability Discrimination Claims in Indiana: Your Complete ADA Guide

Is Your Employer Treating You Differently Because of a Disability?

You showed up. You did your job. And somewhere along the way, your employer started treating you differently, not because of your performance, but because of your disability.

Maybe your request for a reasonable accommodation got ignored. Maybe you were passed over for a promotion after disclosing a medical condition. Maybe your manager suddenly found reasons to write you up after you requested leave for a health issue.

If any of this sounds familiar, you may be experiencing disability discrimination under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

This guide breaks down everything Indiana employees need to know about disability discrimination, from what the ADA covers to how to file a claim, what counts as a reasonable accommodation, and when it makes sense to speak with a disability discrimination attorney in Indiana.

Understanding your rights is the first step. Taking action is the next one.

What Does the ADA Actually Protect Against?

What Is the Americans with Disabilities Act?

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), signed into law in 1990 and significantly expanded in 2008 through the ADA Amendments Act (ADAAA), is a federal civil rights law that prohibits discrimination against individuals with disabilities in several areas of public life, including employment.

Title I of the ADA specifically addresses workplace protections. It applies to private employers with 15 or more employees, as well as state and local governments, employment agencies, and labor organizations.

The core principle is simple: employers cannot treat qualified employees or job applicants unfavorably because of a disability.

What Qualifies as a Disability Under the ADA?

The ADA defines a disability broadly across three categories:

Category	Description
Actual Disability	A physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities
Record of Disability	A history or record of such an impairment (e.g., a past cancer diagnosis)
Regarded as Disabled	Being perceived by the employer as having a disability, even without an actual diagnosis

Major life activities include, but are not limited to:

Walking, standing, lifting, bending
Seeing, hearing, speaking
Breathing, eating, sleeping
Thinking, concentrating, communicating
Caring for oneself
Working
The operation of major bodily functions (immune system, neurological, cardiovascular, etc.)

The ADAAA deliberately broadened these definitions to make it easier for individuals to establish coverage. Courts are now instructed to interpret “substantially limits” generously.

Which Conditions Have Been Recognized Under the ADA?

While each case depends on its specific facts, conditions that courts and the EEOC have generally recognized include:

Cancer
Diabetes
Epilepsy
HIV/AIDS
Blindness or visual impairments
Deafness or hearing loss
Cerebral palsy
Traumatic brain injury
Multiple sclerosis
Depression, bipolar disorder, PTSD, and other mental health conditions
Chronic conditions such as lupus, fibromyalgia, and Crohn’s disease
Mobility impairments requiring assistive devices

The ADA does not cover conditions that are minor or transitory (lasting fewer than six months), casual impairments, or behaviors such as current illegal drug use. However, past addiction that is in recovery may qualify.

What Are Your Rights as an Indiana Employee With a Disability?

What Protections Does the ADA Give You at Work?

If you are a qualified individual with a disability, the ADA protects you across every phase of employment, including:

Hiring and job applications – Employers cannot ask about your disability before offering you a job
Job assignments and duties – You cannot be assigned to lesser roles solely because of your disability
Promotion and advancement – Disability cannot be a factor in denying promotions
Pay and compensation – Disparate pay based on disability is prohibited
Training and professional development – Equal access must be provided
Leave and benefits – Disability-related leave must be treated consistently
Termination – Firing someone because of a disability or disability-related accommodation request is illegal
Harassment – Disability-based harassment that creates a hostile work environment is unlawful

Indiana also has its own law: the Indiana Civil Rights Law, enforced by the Indiana Civil Rights Commission (ICRC). It covers employers with six or more employees and mirrors many ADA protections.

Can an Employer Ask About Your Medical Condition?

This is one of the most misunderstood areas of disability law. The answer depends heavily on timing and context.

Before a conditional job offer: Employers cannot ask questions likely to reveal a disability or require medical exams.

After a conditional job offer: Employers may require medical exams if all candidates for that role undergo the same exam.

During employment: Employers can ask disability-related questions only if there is a legitimate, job-related reason tied to business necessity.

If your employer violated these rules, that alone could form part of a broader claim.

What Is a Reasonable Accommodation and How Does It Work?

What Counts as a Reasonable Accommodation?

One of the most important rights under the ADA is the right to a reasonable accommodation. This refers to any modification or adjustment to the job, work environment, or how things are usually done that enables a qualified individual with a disability to perform the essential functions of their job.

Examples of reasonable accommodations include:

Modified work schedules or flexible hours
Remote work or telecommuting options
Reassignment to a vacant position
Modified equipment or technology (screen readers, ergonomic chairs, voice software)
Leave of absence beyond what FMLA covers
Reserved parking closer to the building
Adjusted dress code requirements for medical devices
Allowing a service animal in the workplace
Written instructions instead of verbal ones for employees with cognitive impairments

“A reasonable accommodation is not a favor. It is a federally protected right.”

The EEOC provides detailed guidance on reasonable accommodations that outlines both employee rights and employer obligations.

What Is the Interactive Process?

Once you request an accommodation, the ADA requires your employer to engage in what is called the interactive process, a good-faith, back-and-forth dialogue between you and your employer to find an effective accommodation.

This process typically involves:

You notify your employer of a need related to a medical condition (a formal request is not required; verbal notice can be sufficient)
Your employer asks for medical documentation if needed (limited to information establishing the disability and functional limitations)
Both parties discuss potential accommodation options
Your employer implements an effective accommodation or demonstrates undue hardship

Employers do not have to provide the exact accommodation you request. They must, however, provide an effective one. If your employer refuses to engage in this process, that refusal can itself be evidence of discrimination.

What Is “Undue Hardship” and Can Your Employer Use It?

An employer can deny a reasonable accommodation only if it causes an undue hardship, meaning significant difficulty or expense when considered in light of factors like:

The cost of the accommodation
The employer’s overall financial resources
The nature of the business and workforce size
The impact on operations

This standard is not easy to meet. Large employers with substantial resources rarely succeed in claiming undue hardship for modest accommodations like flexible scheduling or ergonomic equipment.

What Does Disability Discrimination Actually Look Like at Work?

What Are the Most Common Forms of Workplace Disability Discrimination?

Disability discrimination is not always obvious. It rarely shows up as an employer saying outright, “We’re firing you because of your disability.” More often, it is subtle, layered, and requires careful documentation to prove.

Direct Discrimination:

Being fired shortly after disclosing a diagnosis
Being denied a job because an employer assumes your condition will affect performance
Receiving lower performance ratings after requesting accommodation
Being demoted after returning from disability-related leave

Indirect or Subtle Discrimination:

Being excluded from meetings or communications after requesting accommodation
Being placed on a performance improvement plan (PIP) without prior warnings
Having your job duties reassigned without explanation following a medical leave
Being given a hostile reception or cold treatment after accommodation requests

Failure to Accommodate:

An employer ignoring your accommodation request
Being offered an accommodation that does not address the actual limitation
Having an approved accommodation quietly removed
Being told to “just deal with it” or “everyone has problems”

Harassment Based on Disability:

Offensive comments or jokes about your condition
Mimicking or mocking disability-related behaviors
Repeatedly questioning whether your disability is “real”
Creating an environment where you feel pressured to resign

If any of these experiences resonate with your situation, speaking with an Indiana disability discrimination attorney can help you assess whether you have a viable claim.

Does Indiana Law Add Any Additional Protections?

How Does Indiana Law Interact With the ADA?

Indiana employees benefit from both federal ADA protections and state-level protections under the Indiana Civil Rights Law. While federal law covers employers with 15 or more employees, Indiana’s law applies to employers with six or more employees, which extends protections to workers at smaller businesses.

The ICRC handles state-level complaints, while the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) handles federal ADA claims. These agencies have a work-sharing agreement, meaning filing with one typically cross-files with the other.

Indiana does not have a state equivalent of the ADA that provides significantly broader rights than federal law. However, employees at smaller companies who may fall outside federal coverage should know that Indiana law may still protect them.

For Indiana-specific employment rights, our Indiana Employment Laws resource provides additional context on state-level protections.

How Do You File a Disability Discrimination Claim in Indiana?

What Are the Steps to File an ADA Complaint?

Filing a disability discrimination claim is a structured legal process. Here is what it looks like step by step:

Step 1: Document Everything

Before filing anything, begin building your record. Keep copies of:

Written accommodation requests and employer responses
Emails, texts, or written notes from supervisors
Performance reviews (before and after disclosure)
Medical documentation of your condition and limitations
Witness names and contact information
A personal log of incidents with dates, times, and details

Our guide on how to document workplace harassment in Indiana applies equally to disability discrimination documentation strategies.

Step 2: File a Charge With the EEOC or ICRC

Before you can file a federal lawsuit under the ADA, you must first file a Charge of Discrimination with the EEOC. This is a mandatory step.

Deadlines are critical:

In Indiana, you generally have 300 days from the discriminatory act to file with the EEOC (because Indiana has a state agency that handles such complaints)
Missing this deadline can permanently bar your federal claim

You can file online through the EEOC’s public portal, by mail, or in person at an EEOC field office.

Step 3: EEOC Investigation and Resolution

After filing, the EEOC will:

Notify your employer
Investigate the charge
Attempt mediation or settlement if appropriate
Issue a “Right to Sue” letter if no resolution is reached

Step 4: File a Lawsuit (If Necessary)

Once you receive a Right to Sue letter, you have 90 days to file a lawsuit in federal court. This window is strict. Missing it generally means losing your right to sue under the ADA.

This is why consulting with an Indiana employment lawyer well before deadlines is critical. Understanding these timelines before they pass can make or break your case.

You can also learn more about the full EEOC complaint process through our EEOC Complaint Guide for Indiana.

What Can You Recover If You Win a Disability Discrimination Case?

What Damages Are Available in ADA Claims?

Employees who prevail in ADA disability discrimination cases may be entitled to several types of relief:

Type of Relief	What It Includes
Back Pay	Wages and benefits lost from the time of the discriminatory act
Front Pay	Projected future lost earnings if reinstatement is not feasible
Compensatory Damages	Emotional distress, pain and suffering, inconvenience
Punitive Damages	Available in cases of malicious or reckless employer conduct
Reinstatement	Return to your former position
Reasonable Accommodation	Court-ordered accommodations going forward
Attorney’s Fees and Costs	Recoverable if you prevail

Compensatory and punitive damages under the ADA are subject to caps based on employer size:

15–100 employees: $50,000
101–200 employees: $100,000
201–500 employees: $200,000
501+ employees: $300,000

Back pay and front pay are not subject to these caps.

What Mistakes Could Hurt Your Disability Discrimination Claim?

What Should You Avoid When Pursuing a Disability Claim?

Many employees unintentionally weaken their own cases before speaking with an attorney. Avoid these common mistakes:

Waiting too long to act. The 300-day EEOC filing deadline is not flexible. Many employees wait, hoping things improve or feeling uncertain about their rights. Delay can cost you your claim.

Not putting accommodation requests in writing. Verbal requests are legally valid, but written requests create a paper trail. If your employer later claims they were unaware of your needs, written documentation is your protection.

Signing a severance agreement without legal review. Severance agreements often include broad waivers of legal claims, including ADA claims. Signing without understanding what you are giving up can eliminate your right to sue. Our Indiana severance agreement guide walks through this in detail.

Failing to engage in the interactive process. If your employer invites you to discuss accommodations and you do not respond, it can be used against you. Participate, document, and follow through.

Posting about your situation on social media. Employers and their attorneys monitor public posts. Avoid discussing your claim, your employer, or your medical condition publicly during this process.

Assuming your condition does not qualify. Many employees with conditions like anxiety, ADHD, chronic pain, or autoimmune disorders assume they are not covered. The ADAAA broadened coverage significantly. An attorney evaluation can clarify your status.

How Does Disability Discrimination Connect to Other Employment Rights?

How Does the ADA Interact With FMLA, Workers’ Compensation, and Retaliation?

Disability discrimination claims rarely exist in isolation. They often intersect with other legal protections.

ADA and FMLA

The Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) provides eligible employees up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave for serious health conditions. The ADA may require additional leave as a reasonable accommodation beyond those 12 weeks.

Employees sometimes lose their jobs after taking FMLA leave for a disability-related condition and then face ADA violations when they return. Our Indiana FMLA guide explains how these two protections work side by side.

ADA and Workers’ Compensation

An injury that qualifies for workers’ compensation may also create a disability under the ADA. Employers sometimes terminate workers who file workers’ comp claims, which can create both retaliation and ADA discrimination issues.

Learn how these protections overlap in our breakdown of how workers’ compensation and the ADA interact.

ADA and Retaliation

The ADA prohibits retaliation against employees who:

Request accommodations
File a discrimination complaint
Participate in an investigation
Oppose discriminatory practices

Retaliation often looks like a sudden PIP, unexplained demotion, or termination following an accommodation request. Our Indiana retaliation attorney page explains what retaliation looks like and how to document it.

Wrongful Termination Connected to Disability

If your termination appears connected to your disability, accommodation request, or medical leave, it may qualify as wrongful termination under the ADA. See our detailed guide on how to challenge wrongful termination in Indiana for more information.

What Should You Look for in an Indiana Disability Discrimination Attorney?

How Do You Choose the Right Attorney for Your ADA Claim?

Choosing the right legal representation can significantly affect the outcome of your case. Here is what to look for:

Focus on plaintiff-side employment law. You want an attorney who advocates for employees, not employers. Firms that represent management will have built-in conflicts and a fundamentally different orientation toward your case.

Indiana-specific experience. Employment law involves federal statutes, but it also involves Indiana procedural rules, local court systems, and familiarity with how EEOC offices in Indianapolis handle claims. Local knowledge matters.

Transparent communication. You deserve to understand your case at every stage. An attorney who explains things clearly, answers questions directly, and keeps you informed builds the foundation for a productive attorney-client relationship.

Willingness to evaluate honestly. Not every situation rises to the level of a legal claim. A good attorney will assess your situation honestly, even if the answer is not what you hoped to hear. This protects your time and theirs.

Our guide on what to look for when hiring an Indiana employment attorney offers a detailed breakdown of what to expect from the consultation process.

If you are in the Indianapolis area and wondering what specifically qualifies as actionable, our Indianapolis local employment attorney resource is a good starting point.

We also serve clients across Indiana, including in Fort Wayne, Gary, and Evansville.

What Questions Do Indiana Employees Ask Most About Disability Discrimination?

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Does my employer have to give me exactly the accommodation I asked for?

No. Your employer must provide an effective accommodation but is not required to give you the specific one you requested. They can offer alternatives, as long as those alternatives genuinely address your documented limitations and allow you to perform the essential functions of your job.

2. What if I only work part-time? Am I still protected by the ADA?

Coverage under the ADA is based on the employer’s size, not your hours. If your employer has 15 or more employees, you are covered regardless of whether you are part-time, full-time, or seasonal.

3. Can my employer fire me while I am on medical leave for a disability?

Terminating an employee while they are on disability-related leave can raise serious ADA and FMLA questions. If the termination appears connected to the leave or the underlying disability, it could constitute discrimination. Consult with an attorney before accepting any termination. Our Indiana workplace leave rights guide explains what protections apply during medical leave.

4. Does depression or anxiety count as a disability under the ADA?

Yes, in many cases. Mental health conditions that substantially limit a major life activity, including concentrating, interacting with others, caring for oneself, or working, can qualify as a disability under the ADA. The ADAAA specifically rejected narrow interpretations that excluded mental health conditions. The EEOC’s guidance on mental health conditions provides more detail.

5. I was not officially diagnosed. Can I still have a disability discrimination claim?

Possibly. If your employer treated you as though you had a disability, even without a formal diagnosis, you may be protected under the “regarded as” prong of the ADA. The focus is on how your employer perceived and acted toward you.

6. My employer says my accommodation would be too expensive. What are my options?

Undue hardship is a high standard that employers often struggle to meet for modest accommodations. If your employer denies your request on cost grounds, ask for a written explanation and consult an attorney. Many cost-based denials do not survive legal scrutiny, particularly from mid-to-large employers.

7. Can I sue if I was harassed about my disability but not fired?

Yes. You do not have to be terminated to have a valid ADA claim. Disability-based harassment that is severe or pervasive enough to create a hostile work environment is independently actionable under the ADA. Our sexual harassment page discusses hostile work environment standards that apply broadly across protected classes.

8. What if I work for the Indiana state government?

State government employees are generally covered by the ADA under Title II. However, there are nuances around sovereign immunity and which remedies are available. Consulting with an attorney who understands both federal and state government employment is important.

9. Can I be forced to accept a different job as an accommodation?

Reassignment to a vacant position is a recognized form of accommodation, but it is generally considered a last resort when no accommodation is possible in your current role. Employers cannot demote you or significantly reduce your pay through reassignment. The reassigned position must be a genuine, vacant role for which you are qualified.

10. What if I missed the 300-day EEOC filing deadline?

In most cases, missing this deadline will bar your ADA federal claim. There are limited exceptions for situations involving fraudulent concealment or equitable tolling, but these are narrow. If you believe you missed the deadline, contact an attorney immediately to explore whether any exceptions apply. See our retaliation at work and EEOC complaint guide for related procedural guidance.

11. How long does an ADA case take?

Timelines vary significantly. EEOC investigations can take months to over a year. If litigation follows, cases can take one to three years or more, depending on complexity, whether the case settles, and court scheduling. Many cases resolve through settlement before trial.

12. What if my employer has fewer than 15 employees?

Federal ADA protections generally do not apply. However, Indiana’s Civil Rights Law covers employers with six or more employees. Additionally, depending on your industry or employment contract, other legal theories may apply. Do not assume you have no options. Consulting with an attorney can reveal protections you were unaware of.

Are You Ready to Understand Your Rights?

Disability discrimination is a serious violation of federal and Indiana law. The ADA was designed specifically to ensure that people with disabilities are evaluated on their abilities and not sidelined because of assumptions, stigma, or employer inconvenience.

If your employer ignored your accommodation request, treated you differently after a diagnosis, retaliated against you for asserting your rights, or terminated you in circumstances that feel connected to your disability, those experiences deserve careful legal evaluation.

The team at Amber Boyd Law represents Indiana employees navigating exactly these situations. From Indianapolis to Fort Wayne, Gary, and Evansville, the firm focuses on employment law for individuals, not corporations.

You can also explore these related resources to build your understanding:

Find our Indianapolis office and connect with the team directly on Google Maps.

Schedule Your Case Evaluation

If you believe you have experienced disability discrimination at work in Indiana, speaking with an employment attorney can help you understand what your options are, how strong your case may be, and what steps to take before deadlines pass.

Contact Amber Boyd Law at (317) 960-5070 or reach out through the firm’s contact page to schedule your confidential case evaluation.

You deserve to be evaluated on what you bring to the table, not on a diagnosis.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For guidance specific to your situation, please consult a qualified Indiana employment attorney.

YMM Digital

See Full Bio